2010Flipped from DemocraticFinal resultsIncumbent defeated
2010 election for New York Assembly District 5
New York State Assembly · New York
Alfred C. Graf (R) won with 49.5% of the vote, defeating Kenneth J. Mangan (D) by 20.1 points, a seat Democrats won last time.
Alfred C. GrafRepublican · winner
49.5%17,810
Kenneth J. ManganDemocrat
29.4%10,588
Ginny A. FieldsIndependent · incumbent
21.1%7,579
35,981 votes
Source: Harvard Dataverse / Carl KlarnerUpdated Sep 30, 2026, 7:29 AM ET
The seat over time
D − R margin in this seat's races around 2010
Races before and after
Source: Harvard Dataverse / Carl KlarnerUpdated Sep 30, 2026, 7:29 AM ET