Horizon · our Election Day forecast: polls, plus fundamentals like incumbency, fundraising and past results.

Pulse · polls only: where the races stand today, with no fundamentals and wider uncertainty.

What's the difference?

New York › U.S. House of Representatives · November 3, 2026 · Updated Oct 16, 2026

New York's 2nd District

Fusion

Garbarino is favored to win: Garbarino wins in about 3 of every 4 simulations.

Halpin (D)
23%
chance of winning
Garbarino (R)
77%
Average margin
R+4.9
80% of outcomes
R+14 to D+4
Partisan lean
R+11
Polls
No pollsmodel only

Garbarino is favored to win: Garbarino wins in about 3 of every 5 simulations.

Halpin (D)
37%
chance of winning
Garbarino (R)
63%
Average margin
R+2.8
80% of outcomes
R+15 to D+9
Partisan lean
R+11
Polls
No pollsmodel only

How this race is decided

Fusion voting

Candidates can run on several party lines, such as Working Families or Conservative, and their votes on every line are added together. The forecast counts all of a candidate's lines.

Range of outcomes

Final margin across our simulations; the white dashes mark the middle 80%.

R+4.9R+20R+10EvenD+10D+20
R+2.8R+30R+20R+10EvenD+10D+20D+30

How the odds have moved

Chance of winning by forecast date.

0%25%50%75%100%AugSepOctNovNov 3Halpin 23%Garbarino 77%

Updated nightly. Each day is the current model run on the polls that had ended by then (how).

0%25%50%75%100%AugSepOctNovNov 3Halpin 37%Garbarino 63%

Updated nightly. Each day is the current model run on the polls that had ended by then (how).

The candidates

Democratic

Patrick Halpin

Former Suffolk County executive (1988–1991)

Experience
Local office
Raised
$576.6K
From individuals
$546.1K
Spent
$530.4K
Cash on hand
$46.2K

Money: FEC, through Sep 30, 2026.

Profile and career · Wikipedia

What goes into the forecast

Every ingredient's estimate of the final margin.

National environment
D+9.5Election Day forecast; federal races run in it
Swing reaching this office
78%Of a shift in the environment, from past House races since 2016
Mid-Atlantic adjustment
+0.5How House races in the region have run against lean and environment lately
← RepublicanDemocratic →Lean + environmentUsual vote, shifted by 78% of the environment andthe Mid-Atlantic adjustmentR+2.3Fundamentals modelAdds incumbency, past results, money andexperienceR+5.1Polls in similar placesPolling of similar races in New York andlook-alike placesR+4.3Polling averageNo polls of this racenot availableHorizon forecastPolls + fundamentals, projected to Election DayR+4.9Pulse forecastPolls (and polling of similar places) only, todayR+2.7

Each estimate is a margin before national and statewide uncertainty is simulated. Horizon blends polls, fundamentals and a little of the similar-places estimate, weighting each by how precise it is; Pulse uses polls and similar places only.

Fundamentals inputs
Incumbency (+1 D, −1 R)-1
Fundraising edge (log ratio of individual money)0.09
Elected-experience edge-0.67
First-term incumbent0
Seat's last result vs. expectation-5.79
Incumbent's last result vs. expectation-5.79

Polls

No public polls of this race. The forecast relies on fundamentals and on polling of similar places.

The district

Lean R+11: how much more Democratic or Republican than the nation it votes for president.

Presidential vote

← RepublicanDemocratic →2016 presidentR+7.9R+10.1 vs. nation2020 presidentR+2.5R+7.0 vs. nation2024 presidentR+14.1R+12.6 vs. nation

Precinct results re-aggregated to the current district lines.

Who lives here

Population
702,947
People per km²
541
Adults with a B.A.+
36%
White, no degree
38%of adults
  • White 59%
  • Hispanic 25%
  • Black 9%
  • Asian 4%
  • Other / multiracial 4%

American Community Survey 2020–2024, aggregated from census tracts.

Past results

Results in the same-numbered district; earlier elections may have used different lines.

2024

338,984 votes · R+19.5
✓ Andrew R. Garbarino (R)59.8%
Rob Lubin (D)40.2%

2024 President Vote in this district

358,287 two-party votes · R+14.1 · R+12.6 vs. the nation
✓ Donald Trump (R)57.0%
Kamala Harris (D)43.0%

2022 Earlier district lines

249,151 votes · R+21.5
✓ Andrew R Garbarino (R)60.7%
Jackie Gordon (D)39.2%

2020 Earlier district lines

335,163 votes · R+7.0
✓ Andrew R Garbarino (R)52.9%
Jackie Gordon (D)46.0%
Harry R Burger (G)1.0%

2020 President Vote in this district

361,453 two-party votes · R+2.5 · R+7.0 vs. the nation
✓ Donald Trump (R)51.2%
Joe Biden (D)48.8%

2018 Earlier district lines

241,171 votes · R+6.2
✓ Peter T King (R)53.1%
Liuba Grechen Shirley (D)46.9%

2016 Earlier district lines

292,595 votes · R+24.1
✓ Peter T King (R)62.0%
Duwayne Gregory (D)37.9%

2016 President Vote in this district

312,374 two-party votes · R+7.9 · R+10.1 vs. the nation
✓ Donald Trump (R)53.9%
Hillary Clinton (D)46.1%